Showing posts with label individual mandate. Show all posts
Showing posts with label individual mandate. Show all posts

Thursday, December 19, 2019

5th Circuit Says ACA Individual Mandate Is Unconstitutional

A panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit ruled Dec. 18, in Texas v. United States, that the Affordable Care Act's (ACA's) individual coverage mandate, effectively repealed as of this year, is unconstitutional. But the appellate panel then sent the case back to the district court to adjudicate whether the individual mandate's removal leaves the rest of the law standing.

On Dec. 14, 2018, district court judge Reed O'Connor ruled that because Congress eliminated the penalty on individuals without ACA-compliant health coverage effective in 2019, the ACA's individual mandate requiring people to have health insurance "can no longer be sustained as an exercise of Congress's tax power." O'Connor, who sits in the Northern District of Texas, then struck down the ACA in full, concluding that the individual mandate is so connected to the law that Congress would not have passed the ACA without it. His ruling, however, left the ACA in place pending an appeal to the Fifth Circuit.

On appeal, the split panel of the Fifth Circuit instructed the district court to rehear the matter and to provide additional analysis on whether the rest of the law passes constitutional muster without the individual mandate.

Excerpt from SHRM article By Stephen Miller, CEBSDecember 19, 2019

Thursday, September 20, 2018

Maryland Individual Health Insurance Plans Poised for First Rate Reduction

Maryland individuals who purchase health insurance through the state's five-year-old Affordable Care Act exchange are poised to see the first decrease in their premium costs in 2019.

Following federal approval of a program that aims to stabilize the ACA-born insurance market, Kaiser Permanente and CareFirst BlueCross BlueShield are seeking price decreases for their individual market plans. The drop follows four consecutive years of double-digit percentage hikes. Consumer advocacy groups present at a public hearing on Monday lauded insurance officials' efforts around lowering prices, and said the decreases will be a welcome relief for residents who do not qualify for employer-based coverage and must purchase plans through the state's exchange.

The effort was initiated by a piece of bipartisan legislation passed in the Maryland General Assembly earlier this year. Maryland will put hundreds of millions of dollars behind a reinsurance program, which will allow the state's lone two carriers in the individual market to see major cost savings and stave off the need to again increase premium prices in 2019.

The Maryland Insurance Administration said during the hearing it is still finalizing details with the insurers, and plans to release the final 2019 rates later this week. Pending any major adjustments, the rates will look close to this:

CareFirst's individual HMO members will see about a 22.3 percent premium decrease, and a $104 monthly price decrease compared to 2018 rates.

Kaiser's individual HMO members will see about a 6.3 percent premium decrease, about a $23 per month swing from 2018.

CareFirst's individual PPO members — they are generally the sickest and most costly members in the market overall — will see about a 17.7 percent premium increase, which would result in an average price increase of about $121 per month compared to last year's rates.

Prior to the approval of Maryland's reinsurance plan, requested 2019 rates ranged between 18 percent to more than 90 percent increases. Now, insurers are seeking an average 13.9 decrease overall.

Peter Berry, chief actuary at CareFirst, the state's dominant health insurer, said he's scanned through the company's rate trends for the past 20 years. If the decrease is cleared, he said it would mark this first time in that period that some CareFirst members would see a year-over-year decrease in premiums.

"For the first time since I’ve been looking at health insurance since 1985, I’m speechless in a very good way," said Beth Sammis, president of advocacy group Consumer Health First. "This is a good day for consumers."

Sammis said next, industry officials need to put their efforts behind making sure that Maryland individual consumers understand their new options, and actually purchase these plans for the coming year.

Insurance Commissioner Al Redmer said part of the goal of the reinsurance program is to lure consumers who have opted to go without insurance the last few years due to unaffordability back to the market. The more people who pay into in a given insurance risk pool, the greater the price stability for everyone in the pool.

In an excerpt by Morgan Eichensehr  – Reporter, Baltimore Business Journal
Sep 17, 2018, 2:53pm

Thursday, December 7, 2017

House and Senate Tax Reform Comparison Chart

House and Senate Tax Reform Proposal Comparison



Employer-Provided Retirement Plans

H.R. 1, Tax Cuts and Jobs ActSenate Proposal, Tax Cuts and Jobs Act
Defined Contribution Retirement Plans
Preserves the current tax treatment of employer-provided plans
Defined Contribution Retirement Plan Loans
Changes repayment time frame on retirement plan loans from 60 days after separation of employment to end of the federal taxable year. Effective for plan years after 2017.
Changes repayment options for 457 and 403(b) plans to allow rollovers or loan repayment to take place by the end of the federal taxable year. Effective for tax years after 2017.
Defined Benefit Pension Plan Non-Discrimination Clarity
Provides relief for defined benefit pension plans that are soft-frozen. Allows cross-testing of participants in order to not violate non-discrimination testing limits. Effective upon date of enactment.
Proposal does not contain this provision.
457 Retirement Plan Changes
 Bill does not contain this provision.
Sets deferral and catch-up contribution limits at the same levels as 401(k) and 403(b) plans. Also repeals former allowable contributions to 457 plans for up to five years after separation of employment. Effective for tax years after 2017.
In-Service Distributions for Defined Contribution Plans
Would allow all defined benefit plans as well as state and local government defined contribution plans to make in-service distributions beginning at age 59½. Effective for plan years after 2017.Proposal does not contain this provision.
Defined Benefit Retirement Plan Contributions After Hardship Withdrawal
IRS would be required within one year of the date of enactment to change its guidance to allow employees taking hardship distributions to continue making contributions to the plan. Effective for plan years after 2017.Proposal does not contain this provision.
Defined Benefit Retirement Plan Hardship Withdrawals
Employers who choose to allow hardship distributions could also include employer contributions as part of the amount eligible for withdrawal. Effective for plan years after 2017.Proposal does not contain this provision.

Executive Compensation
H.R. 1, Tax Cuts and Jobs ActSenate Proposal, Tax Cuts and Jobs Act
Compensation
Removes the exemption of certain forms of compensation for highly compensated employees. Commissions, performance-based remuneration, stock options, payments to a tax-qualified retirement plan and amounts that are excludable from the executive’s gross income will be taxable.  Expands the scope of covered individuals to include an organization’s CEO, CFO and three highest-paid employees.  Effective for tax years after 2017.Modifies the definition of what is included as compensation for highly compensated employees to include commission- and performance-based compensation. Expands the scope of covered individuals to include an organization’s CEO, CFO and three highest-paid employees. Applies provision to any compensation arrangement entered into after November 3, 2017.
Excise Tax on Highly Compensated Employees at Non-Profits
Creates a 20 percent excise tax for non-profits (including 501(c)(3), 501(c)(6)) on the compensation of the five highest-paid employees who earn more than $1 million. Effective for tax years after 2017.
Employer-Provided Benefits
H.R. 1, Tax Cuts and Jobs ActSenate Proposal, Tax Cuts and Jobs Act
Education Assistance (Section 127)
Eliminates the tax exclusion that allows employers to provide up to $5,250 of education assistance per year tax-free to their employees at the undergraduate, graduate or certificate level. Benefit would be taxable to both the employer and the employee. Effective for tax years after 2017.Proposal does not contain this provision.
Tuition Reduction (Section 117)
Eliminates the tax exclusion for educational assistance for employees, their spouse or dependents at educational institutions. Benefit would be taxable to both the employer and the employee. Effective for tax years after 2017.Proposal does not contain this provision.
Dependent Care Accounts
Eliminates the tax treatment of dependent care flexible spending accounts of up to $5,000 per year under Section 129. Effective after 2022.Proposal does not contain this provision.
Moving Expenses
Eliminates the tax exclusion and the deduction related to moving expenses. Value of the benefit will be included as taxable income and the deduction will be eliminated for individual taxpayers. Effective for tax years after 2017.Suspends the tax exclusion and the deduction related to moving expenses until 2025. Value of the benefit will be included as taxable income, and the deduction will be eliminated for individual taxpayers. 
Biking Benefit
Bill does not contain this provision. Eliminates the tax exclusion on the benefit. Value of the benefit will be included as taxable income. Exclusion will be sunset in December 2025. 
Adoption Assistance
Eliminates the tax exclusion on the benefit. Value of the benefit will be included as taxable income for individual taxpayers. Effective for tax years after 2017.Proposal does not contain this provision. 
Achievement Awards 
Eliminates the tax exclusion on the benefit. Value of the benefit will be included as taxable income for individual taxpayers. Effective for tax years after 2017.Proposal does not contain this provision. 
Child Care Facilities
Repeals the tax credit equal to 25 percent of qualified expenses for employee child care and 10 percent of qualified expenses for child care resource and referral services. Effective for tax years after 2017. Proposal does not contain this provision. 
​Fringe Benefits
(Transportation, Meals, Gyms)
Taxes tax-exempt entities on the values of providing their employees with transportation fringe benefits, on-premises gyms and other athletic facilities by treating the funds used to pay for such benefits as unrelated business taxable income, thus subjecting the values of those employee benefits to a tax equal to the corporate tax rate. Value of the benefit will be included as taxable income. Effective for tax years after 2017.Proposal does not contain this provision. 
Medical Savings Accounts (MSAs)
Repeals the tax exclusion for contributions to Archer MSAs. Existing Archer MSA balances, however, could continue to be rolled over on a tax-free basis to an HSA. Effective for tax years after 2017.Proposal does not contain this provision. 
Other Related Provisions
H.R. 1, Tax Cuts and Jobs ActSenate Proposal, Tax Cuts and Jobs Act
Work Opportunity Tax Credit
Repeals the 40 percent tax credit for employers who hired individuals from certain targeted groups. Effective for tax years after 2017.Proposal does not contain this provision.
FICA Tip Credit Tax
Modifies the calculation that affects the amount employers pay on taxable wages of their tipped employees. Creates a new reporting requirement. Effective for tax years after 2017.Proposal does not contain this provision.
Intermediate Sanctions on Non-Profits
Bill does not contain this provision.Applies intermediate sanctions rules to 501(c)(5) and 501(c)(6) organizations, levying a 10 percent tax on the organization for willful violations. Eliminates the safe harbor for non-profits that exercise due diligence in determining compensation. Effective for tax years after 2017.
Repeal of the Individual Mandate Penalty Under the Affordable Care Act
Bill does not contain this provision.Reduces the individual mandate penalty to zero. Effective for tax years after 2018.
Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) Credit for Employers
Bill does not contain this provision.Provides an employer a credit of 12.5 percent of the wages paid to a qualified employee utilizing FMLA. Effective for tax years after 2017.
*Proposals as of November 25, 2017.  Posted from SHRM.

Thursday, March 9, 2017

Legislative Update: ACA Repeal, Replace Advances Through House

Early this morning the House Ways and Means Committee approved the American Health Care Act—to replace tax elements of the Affordable Care Act (ACA)—by a vote of 23-16.
House Republican leadership introduced the legislation March 6. The American Health Care Act was created under the budget reconciliation process and requirements and is limited in its scope to amend only the tax provisions of the ACA. It does not amend the insurance and the underlying coverage requirements of the ACA. Using this process allows supporters of the American Health Care Act to pass changes to the ACA in the Senate with a simple majority of 51 votes instead of the 60 votes needed to override an expected Democratic filibuster. 
In introducing the legislation, House Speaker Paul Ryan outlined three steps Congress and the Trump Administration will now take to replace the ACA:
  1. Pass the American Health Care Act.
  2. Make additional changes to the rules that govern the ACA through the regulatory process.
  3. Work with Democrats to pass legislation to address the insurance elements of the ACA that need reform, which will require support of Senate Democrats in order to avert a filibuster. 
The Ways and Means and Energy and Commerce Committees began work on the bill this week and the legislation will likely change as it works its way through the legislative process.  The House Budget Committee is expected during the week of March 13 to package the Ways and Means language with provisions from the Energy and Commerce Committee, which is yet to vote on the bill. If passed by the Committees, the legislation could be considered by the full House as early as the week of March 20.
Key issues of interest to the HR profession and the workplace: 
  • Reduces employer mandate penalty. Under current law, certain employers are required to provide health insurance or pay a penalty. This bill would reduce the penalty to zero for failure to provide minimum essential coverage. The employer mandate will remain and would have to be repealed through future legislation. The effective date would apply beginning after December 31, 2015, providing retroactive relief to those impacted by the penalty in 2016.
  • Reduces individual mandate penalty. Under current law, most individuals are required to purchase health insurance or pay a penalty. This bill would reduce the penalty to zero for failure to maintain minimum essential coverage. The individual mandate will remain and would have to be repealed through future legislation. The effective date would apply beginning after December 31, 2015, providing retroactive relief to those impacted by the penalty in 2016.  
  • Creates a continuous coverage requirement surcharge. This bill creates a new continuous coverage requirement surcharge. To avoid a 30 percent premium surcharge, individuals must prove that they did not have a gap in creditable coverage beyond 63 continuous days during the 12 months preceding coverage. Individuals aging out of dependent coverage must prove that they enrolled during the first open enrollment period after which dependent coverage ceased. The penalty does not vary by health status but would be greater for older individuals since premiums may vary with age. The penalty lasts for the remainder of the plan year for special enrollments during 2018, and for the 12-month period beginning with the first day of the plan year for 2019 and succeeding years.
  • Delays excise tax on high-value health care plans. The ACA imposed a 40 percent excise tax on high cost employer-sponsored health coverage to benefits exceeding certain thresholds ($10,200 for individual coverage and $27,500 for family coverage). Under current law, the tax is scheduled to go into effect in 2020. This bill changes the effective date of the tax for taxable periods beginning after Dec. 31, 2024.
  • Repeals the health insurance tax. The ACA imposed an annual fee on certain health insurers. The proposal repeals this health insurance tax beginning after Dec. 31, 2017.
  • Repeals increase of tax on HSAs. The ACA increased the percentage of the tax on distributions that are not used for qualified medical expenses to 20 percent. This bill lowers the rate to pre-ACA percentages. This change is effective for distributions after Dec. 31, 2017.
  • Repeals the limit on contributions to FSAs. The ACA limits the amount an employer or individual may contribute to a health Flexible Spending Account (FSA) to $2,500, indexed for cost-of-living adjustments. This bill repeals the limitation on health FSA contributions for taxable years beginning after Dec. 31, 2017.
As noted above, the bill does not repeal the ACA insurance reforms, including the following health plan requirements:
    • Coverage of pre-existing conditions;
    • Guarantee availability and renewability of coverage;
    • Coverage of adult children up to age 26;
    • Cap out-of-pocket expenditures;
    • Prohibitions against health status underwriting, lifetime and annual limits, and discrimination on the basis of race, nationality, disability, age, or sex.
Since the legislation does not eliminate the employer mandate, employer reporting requirements under the ACA would not change.
-SHRM-By Chatrane Birbal, March 9, 2017

Wednesday, February 22, 2017

IRS will continue to accept 'silent' individual tax returns

FEB 17, 2017 | BY JESSICA LEDONNE

Becoming the first agency to take action in response to President Trump’s executive order directing federal agencies “minimize...the economic and regulatory burdens of the Act”, the IRS has told tax preparers that it will not automatically reject individual returns that do not state whether or not the filer had health coverage.

Although at first blush, accepting such “silent” returns would appear to be a loosening of the enforcement of the ACA’s individual mandate, this is not actually a change in policy, as the agency accepted and processed over 4 million silent returns last year.

The information, coming in an email correspondence rather than a formal rule or release, stated that the IRS would “continue to allow electronic and paper returns to be accepted for processing in instances where a taxpayer doesn’t indicate their coverage status.” The email went on to confirm that this did not impact taxpayers’ responsibility to obtain health insurance or to pay a penalty, even reiterating that the ACA is “still in force” and that “taxpayers remain required to follow the law and pay what they may owe‎.” Therefore, although these silent returns won’t be automatically rejected, they may eventually lead to questions, audits, or eventual penalties.

Ultimately, experts seem to agree that the decision to continue to accept returns with no health coverage information will not have much of an impact on the ACA’s individual mandate requirements, but rather, is the IRS confirming that they will continue to do what they’ve previously done.

Wednesday, December 30, 2015

IRS Delays 1094/1095 Reporting

 January 31st, 2016 for statements given to employees/individuals and February 29th for transmittal's filed to the IRS (and WAS March 31st if you are filing over 250 employee statements to employees).  Keep in mind, this is the information that the IRS will use to penalize the individual or the employer if they are not offering appropriate and affordable coverage and is used by the individual when preparing their personal tax returns. 

Now, the IRS announced that it will be giving employers additional time.  According to Notice Notice 2016-4, the IRS is delaying filing deadlines to allow employers, insurers and other providers additional time to get information together for the reporting.  The NEW deadlines are:


  • Statements given to employees/individuals is now March 31, 2016 (Two Additional Months)
  • Transmittal's filed to IRS (Paper) is now May 31st, 2016 (Three Additional Months)
  • Transmittal's filed electronically in now June 30th, 2016 (Three Additional Months)

Hope you find this information helpful and Happy New Years!


Wednesday, March 5, 2014

Obama administration allows health plan renewals for two more years

WASHINGTON Wed Mar 5, 2014 6:10pm EST
(Reuters) - The Obama administration said on Wednesday it would allow health insurers to extend plans that fail to comply with its signature healthcare law for an additional two years, giving some consumers the option of keeping their policies into 2017.
In a release of comprehensive insurance guidelines for next year, officials also said the government was extending the 2015 open enrollment by one month to create a three-month period running from November 15, 2014, to February 15, 2015.
The guidelines also presented an early glimpse of the cost of Obamacare-compliant plans, saying the annual cap on out-of-pocket expenses for consumers would rise to $6,600 for individuals and $13,200 for families. Expenses are currently capped at $6,350 for an individual and $12,700 for a family.
The change in the renewal policy could help Democrats in November's congressional elections by eliminating the possibility of a new wave of insurance plan cancellations just before the vote. It also allows some policies to be continued past the November 2016 presidential election.
But administration officials described the guidelines as a response to conversations with a range of stakeholders including consumers, insurers and state regulators. They said the number of people affected, estimated at between 500,000 and 1.5 million, was expected to shrink rapidly as consumers shift into Obamacare-compliant policies.
The initial decision to allow one-year renewals last November followed a public outcry as millions of consumers received notice from insurers that their plans would be canceled because they did not comply with Obamacare's consumer protection standards.
Officials said on Wednesday the change would require them to adjust a risk mitigation program to protect insurers from unexpected losses, and indicated that they could relax a consumer-protection rule that currently prohibits insurers from spending more than 20 percent of plan revenues on administrative costs including marketing.

(Reporting by David Morgan; Editing by Peter Cooney)
-------Sadly all of those people who liked their medical plans but were pushed into ACA compliant plans won't be able to get them back....BBS

Friday, December 20, 2013

MORE CHANGES IN HEALTH REFORM FROM THE OBAMA ADMINISTRATION

Once again the Obama administration is making changes to the Affordable Care Act Law. "If you want to keep your health plan, you can keep your health plan".  When this was found out to be untrue, the Obama administration changed the law to allow the States to make the decision if they wanted individuals losing their coverage be allowed to keep it. This ends up falling on the insurance companies who have been working feverishly to abide by the laws under the ACA, spending millions and millions of dollars on technology, compliance and communication to make sure their insureds don't fall through the cracks only to have to go back and say "never mind President Obama says it's OK to keep your plan".  Well, many insurance companies said no or gave a small window of time to go back and re-enroll in their previous plan.  However, this was only for a year and would then need to elect a reform plan.  So, now, because their are still so many uninsured's the administration is allowing those individuals who lost their coverage be allowed to purchase "Catastrophic" coverage under the reform plans under the "hardship provision".  Normally, these plans are only reserved for people under 30 years old (young and invincible plans). Keep in mind though, you may still end paying more for that catastrophic plan than you were paying for your previous plan you were forced to give up under the Affordable Care Act. As it stands now, if you were one of those people who gave up their personal plan and are not able to get that plan back, the individual mandate does not apply to you for another year.


Thursday, November 21, 2013

CAREFIRST DECIDES HOW TO HANDLE THE PRESIDENTS CHANGE OF HEART

As we all know the President is now allowing the states to decide whether they let individuals keep their plans if they want. (Even if they aren't grandfathered)  It appears that this would only be a one year reprieve in any regard.  It also passes the buck to the States.  There was also a question if small employer groups would be allowed to remain with their current plans without having to be forced into reform coverage.  According to Carefirst, Individuals who have received termination notices will be given the opportunity to remain on their current plans if they renew them by mid-December.  In reference to the small group employers (those under 50 full-time employees)  there will be no change from current procedure.  In other words, non-grandfathered small group plans will need to move to reform plans at their renewal in 2014.  

Thursday, November 14, 2013

NEVERMIND, YOU CAN KEEP YOUR PLAN.....ATLEAST FOR INDIVIDUALS

Today in a statement from the President, individual policyholders will now be allowed to maintain their current health plan if they so choose.  This was on the heels of tremendous pressure put on the President because of statements made by him....."if you like your health plan, you can keep your health plan, period".  As we all know this turned out to be untrue.  What seems to be overlooked are all of the individuals and families in employer based coverage being forced into reform plans. (Employer Group Under 50 Employees)  If employer based plans are not "Grandfathered" same as individual market, they would lose their current plan and be forced into a plan that now conforms to the Affordable Care Act (health reform).  The individual market is being addressed, the small group employer market is being overlooked.  


Tuesday, October 29, 2013

INDIVIDUAL MANDATE DEADLINE DELAYED

With the roll-out of the Health Exchanges on October 1, 2013 came a host of problems and computer glitches that kept would-be participants from enrolling in Exchange Plans through the Maryland State and/or Federal Websites.  Due to these hurdles, the Administration is pushing the Individual Mandate Date (date which most citizens must have coverage or face a penalty) back from January 1, 2014 to March 31, 2014.  Many senate democrats are also calling for a push-back on the "Open Enrollment" time-frame as well.  

Wednesday, July 10, 2013

POSSIBLE DELAYS TO THE INDIVIDUAL MANDATE UNDER TRANSITION RELIEF

According to IRS Notice 2013-42, for non-calendar year Medical Plans, transition relief is available for those plans that begin in 2013 and end in 2014.  If your coverage is available through an employer, depending upon when that coverage is made available to you (or your spouse) would depend upon when you would need to obtain coverage.

Example 1. You are eligible for enrollment in a non-calendar year employer sponsored medical plan beginning August 1, 2013 and ending July 31, 2014.  You have parent/child coverage for you and your 10-year old son.  You do not elect coverage for yourself/son on August 1, 2013.  Under this rule you would have transition relief through July 31, 2014.  If you do not elect coverage at this time, penalties would be assessed.

Example 2. You are Married and both you and your spouse are eligible for enrollment in a Non-Calendar Year Plan of an Employer for the 2013-2014 Plan Year and in a Calendar Year Plan with your Spouse’s Employer for 2014.  Your plan begins August 1, 2013 and ends July 31, 2014.  Your spouses plan begins January 1, 2014.  You do not elect coverage for you and your spouse under your plan August 1, 2013 and your spouse does not elect coverage for the both of you on January 1, 2014. In this example both you and your spouse would have transition relief until your plan renewal in August of 2014.  If at this time, no coverage was elected, penalties would be assessed.

(From IRS Notice 2013-42)

Thursday, May 2, 2013

HEALTH REFORM: WHAT ABOUT THE KIDS?'

I just received a call from a client who said "What about the kids?  If coverage is affordable at work for me but not when I add my children and/or spouse, then what?"  Well, that's a great question.  Since affordability is only contingent on the cost as it pertains to individual cost and earnings (no more that 9.5% of W-2 income), it doesn't take into consideration the financial impact of family health care costs.  So, depending upon the income level of the family, the children may be eligible for the Children's Health Insurance Program or "CHIPS".  In addition if the household income does not qualify them for the CHIPS program, Children Only health plans will be made available on the exchange at the same coverage levels as adults (bronze, silver, gold, platinum, etc).  It is also important to note that there are tax penalties associated with not having medical coverage starting January, 2014 (Individual Mandate).  However, in a separate proposed regulation the IRS stated that uninsured children and spouse of an employee will not be subject to the individual mandate if the cost of coverage for the entire family was more than 8% of household income.  Of course that will be up to each individual family to prove to the IRS.




Thursday, April 4, 2013

Maryland Delaying The Launch of the Small Business Exchange


The state’s health department changed the start date for businesses to enroll in the small business exchange from October, 2013 to January 2014. The state’s decision comes after the federal government said it would give states until January 2015 to get up and running a key piece of the small business exchange that gives employees more insurance options.
The health insurance marketplaces for both small businesses and individuals were supposed to begin enrollment this October for coverage that would take effect in January. The individual exchange is still expected to stick to that timeline. The exchanges are part of the federal Affordable Care Act.
Excerpt from the Baltimore Business Journal, April 3, 2013

Thursday, June 28, 2012

SUPREME COURT UPHOLDS THE INDIVIDUAL MANDATE

At approximately 10:00 today, in a vote of 5-4 Chief Justice Roberts, siding with the liberal Justices, read that the Individual Mandate under the Affordable Care Act (Health Reform) is constitutional not as interstate commerce but as a tax.  In other words the government can't force individuals to purchase health care but they can impose a tax penalty if they don't.  


For people in favor of the law, this is an obvious win in their direction.  However, people not in favor of the law, the President, or continued government over-reach could see this as helpful for Romney's presidential bid in November.

Monday, April 2, 2012

HAGGLING OVER HEALTHCARE-A SUPREME DECISION

Is making individuals pay for health insurance or pay a penalty constitutional?  That, over three days last week, was being argued in front of the US Supreme Court.  At this point it's any body's guess, however, a decision will be reached sometime in June. 

In additional to the individual mandate, what else will need to be taken out of the Health Reform Law in order to protect it from abuse?  At the very least, guaranteed issue coverage would need to be taken off the table.  And possibly open enrollment periods added in.  Without this there would be no way to protect from people jumping on and off plan when they needed care......which would be catastrophic. 

During the several days of testimony the more liberal Justices seemed to drive questions that would uphold the law while the conservative Justices were not as sure about congress' power regarding making people purchase health coverage.  The Justices include 5 Republicans and 4 Democrats. 

This is a very big deal to the Obama Administration.  He has even issued a "Challenge" to the Supreme Court to uphold the law.  If this law fails or at least a major portion (Individual Mandate), it could have devastating impacts on his re-election effort.

Monday, November 14, 2011

SUPREME COURT TO HEAR HEALTH CARE LAW CASE

The US Supreme Court announced that it will hear over 5 hours of oral argument regarding the legality of certain provisions under the health care law (PPACA).  In particular below is the allotted times for each argument to be heard:

  • 90 Minutes-Whether the entire health care law should be terminated if the "Individual Mandate" is ruled unconstitutional. 
  • 120 Minutes-Did Congress have the power under Article 1 of the Constitution to enact the Affordable Care Act? (Article 1 regulates interstate commerce and other laws under Congressional Authority they are able to pass)
  • 60 Minutes-determine if the Supreme Court should rule on whether the individual Mandate Penalty constitutes a tax.  This would thereby trigger a federal statute called the anti-injunction act.  They may not be able to rule on this as there hasn't been any tax levied since this provision doesn't go into effect until 2014 (This is required under the anti-injunction act)
  • 60 Minutes-Determining the Constitutionality of Congress allowing the Federal Government to allow states to gain funding based on their participation in the Laws Health Care Reforms.
 Arguments are slated to be heard sometime in mid-March with decisions possibly by the end of June prior to the summer break. 

Friday, August 19, 2011

Individual Mandate Ruled Unconstitutional

On June 6th, 2011 a federal appeals court in Cincinnati ruled that the Individual Mandate (the portion of the reform law that states all individuals must have health insurance) was constitutional.  This was the first appellate court to rule on the issue.  Well, on August 12, 2011 a second federal appeals court in Atlanta has ruled the Individual Mandate as unconstitutional.  When ruling, they stated that this provision, although unconstitutional, is "severable" from the rest of the legislation.  This means that the Individual Mandate would be eliminated but the rest of the law would remain. 

Since there are now two federal courts that have ruled on the issue and have split their decision, it makes it much more likely that this issue will be in front of the U.S. Supreme Court as early as the fall with a decision in 2012.



Thursday, February 10, 2011

Florida Stopping Implementation of PPACA (Health Reform)

This is a follow-up to the previous post, District Court Judge Roger Vinson Just Said No, Too!  As a result of the recent federal court ruling, by U.S District Judge Roger Vinson, which declared PPACA or at least the Individual Mandate to be unconstitutional, Florida has stopped the implementation of the law.  Florida Governor Rick Scott said, "We're not going to spend a lot of time and money with regard to trying to get ready to implement that until we know exactly what is going to happen and I hope and believe that either it will be declared unconstitutional or it will be repealed.  Florida Insurance Commissioner Kevin McCarty stated, "PPACA, a major component of the federal Affordable Care Act package, is not now in effect in Florida."  In addition McCarty said that he told the director of HHS (Health and Human Services) Office of the Consumer Information and Oversight, that Florida would not be spending any of the funds it had been allocated to implement the insurance exchange program. 

Since there were 25 other states that also were part of the lawsuit, I wonder how many of them will make decisions, at the state level, to stop implementation until a final determination has been made?  Final determinations could take as long as two years. 

Tuesday, February 1, 2011

District Court Judge Roger Vinson Just Said No, Too!

On January 31, 2011 District Court Judge Roger Vinson declared the "Individual Mandate" of the PPACA (Health Reform) unconstitutional.  Vinson stated, "because the individual mandate is unconstitutional and not severable, the entire act must be void."  So the count is 2-2.  Judges in Michigan and Virginia, both democrat appointees, have ruled the Health Reform constitutional and Judges in Virginia and now Florida, both republican appointees,  have ruled, at least the individual mandate, as unconstitutional.  The Department of Justice is going to appeal the decision which was filed in March of 2010 by Florida but then 25 other states joined the suit.  The case will ultimately be heard in the Supreme Court which could take up to two years. 

As it stands now, in 2014, if someone doesn't purchase health insurance they will pay a fine of $95 per year or 1% of income whichever is greater and by 2017 amount goes to $695 or 2.5% of income to a maximum of 3X the individual penalty.  In addition, if you earn up to $14,000 you get coverage for free, up to $44,000 and it's subsidized.  Big freaking deal!  Since it's guaranteed issue, I'll take my chances and get coverage when I'm sick. 
Non-payers will receive a notice from the IRS.  If they don’t pay, the IRS will take it from their tax refund in the future.  If they continue to not pay the fine, they will not be subject to any criminal prosecution or penalties.  The secretary cannot file a notice of lien or file a levy on any property.  As stated in a previous post, this penalty has no teeth! 
So my question is what do the democrats do if the individual mandate is ultimately and finally deemed to be unconstitutional?  Do they allow each state to individually allow the reform?  If so, I'm thinking every sick person and their mother will flock to that state for guaranteed issue health care coverage with crushing claims that will make the coverage unaffordable for everyone else.  Or do they come back with a plan that doesn't create a penalty for not having coverage, but just increase taxes and give it to everyone?

Interestingly, some republicans and democrats are trying to come up with ideas that wouldn't require people to carry coverage but would encourage.  For example, people would be given a deadline to enroll and if that deadline is missed, they would have to satisfy long waiting periods.  Or people who apply late and are eligible for tax credits could be penalized by reducing their subsidies.  (sounds like a penalty to me)

Wouldn't it be great if healthy people paid less for coverage, sick people paid a bit more and for those who are truly unable to afford it, given help?  Instead of throwing all this money at bigger government to wrangle this thing, use it to help those who need it the most.